We once had a report saying a client's portfolio was badly underperforming. The same listings, checked on the same day, were beating their market comfortably. Both numbers were correct. Only one of them was useful.
Same listings, two answers
The first report measured the next 90 days. In a market where most guests book around two to three weeks ahead, almost nothing past the first few weeks is booked for anyone. So a 90-day forward view mostly measures how empty the future is. It made the portfolio look like it was losing to the market.
The second view measured the last 30 nights already stayed. On those nights the same listings were well ahead of their comp set.
A forward window that runs past the booking window doesn't measure performance. It measures the calendar.
How I measure instead
- Judge performance on nights already stayed. Trailing 30 or 90 days of actual revenue, occupancy and rate, against the market over the same nights.
- Use forward data only for pace, and only inside the booking window: how much of next month is on the books today compared with this time last year.
- Compare the same listings year over year. Listings live in both periods, the same months a year apart. New units added since can't flatter the result.
- Watch the averages. Booking-window figures are often means, and a handful of bookings made six months ahead can drag the average far above what most guests do. Look at the median.
Why it matters
A wrong measurement leads to the wrong action. An operator who believes they're losing will cut prices on dates that simply haven't been booked yet, and give away money on nights that would have sold at full rate a week later.
Before you change a price, check which window the number you're looking at comes from.
I'm Vivek Kumar Singh, co-founder and COO of RevOpt.ai and co-founder of RevBnB.ai. We run revenue management for 50+ short-term rental operators. If you'd like a second pair of eyes on your pricing, book a 30-minute call.
