When I ask an operator how they price, the most common answer is the name of a tool. "We use PriceLabs." "We're on Wheelhouse." That tells me what sets the rates. It doesn't tell me whether the rates are right.
A dynamic pricing tool is very good at one job: moving prices up and down inside the rules you gave it. It reads demand, compares you with a set of similar listings and adjusts. What it can't do is notice that the rules themselves are wrong.
The tool sets rates inside the settings it is given. Someone has to check, every week, that those settings are still right.
Where the money actually leaks
In our audits the leaks are almost never "the algorithm is bad". They are settings that were sensible the day they were entered and quietly went stale:
- The comp set. If the tool compares your three-bedroom villa with studios two kilometres away, every price it suggests is anchored to the wrong market.
- Base and minimum prices. A minimum set last winter can sit far too low in peak season, or far too high in a soft month, and the tool will respect it either way.
- Minimum stays and gap rules. A three-night minimum that made sense in August can leave Tuesday-to-Thursday gaps empty all autumn.
- Events. A concert or a conference that the tool hasn't priced in yet gets sold out at a normal weekday rate months ahead.
- Promotions on the channels. Airbnb and Booking.com discounts sit on top of the tool's price. Set them carelessly and they undo its work.
What a strategy looks like
A strategy starts with a number: what each listing should earn this month and this year, and how much of that should already be on the books by today. Then, every week, you compare that pace with reality and change the settings that explain the gap. Sometimes that means raising prices on dates selling too fast. Sometimes it means loosening a minimum stay that is blocking bookings.
That weekly loop of goal, pace, diagnosis and settings is the part a tool doesn't do. It's the reason we started RevOpt, and it's the discipline we built into RevBnB for operators who don't have a revenue manager.
A five-minute check you can do today
- Open your comp set and ask: would a guest really choose between these and my listing?
- Look at your minimum price for the next 60 days. Is it ever the price you're actually selling at? If so, it's doing the pricing, not the tool.
- List every active promotion on every channel, and write down which nights each one applies to.
If any of those answers surprises you, the tool isn't the problem. The settings are.
I'm Vivek Kumar Singh, co-founder and COO of RevOpt.ai and co-founder of RevBnB.ai. We run revenue management for 50+ short-term rental operators. If you'd like a second pair of eyes on your pricing, book a 30-minute call.
